Publication
HHS delegates exclusion authority to CMS
HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. announced that the CMS would exercise exclusion authority to remove “bad actors” from federal healthcare programs “effective immediately.”
Global | Publication | August 2026
Reproduced with the permission of Thomson Reuters, these chapters were first published in Practical Law.
Businesses typically conduct consumer sales promotions as an incentive for consumers to purchase a product or service, or to strengthen brand awareness. Consumer sales promotions may involve price discounts, including coupons, rebates, and free offers, or the awarding of prizes through a sweepstakes or contest. These promotions are subject to laws and regulations typically designed to protect the consumer from deceptive and unfair practices.
Because consumer sales promotions involve advertisements for the particular product or service, the promotion itself, or a prize, they are also subject to the restrictions imposed by advertising laws and regulations, such as the prohibition of false and misleading advertising, or in the case of lotteries certain rules on gaming and betting apply. Consumer sales promotions also often involve the collection of personal information from consumers, so businesses need to comply with applicable data privacy laws and regulations.
This Note focuses on the legal issues relating to consumer sales promotions in Italy. It discusses:
This Note also provides tips and best practices for conducting compliant consumer sales promotions.
Consumer sales promotions are subject to range of laws and regulations. These laws and regulations not only govern the conduct of the promotion itself, but also how the promotion is advertised and how personal information may be collected, shared, and used.
Several laws and regulations apply to sales promotions in Italy, including:
Promoters must comply with the following obligations:
Promoters must also comply with data protection rules in the processing of personal data for advertising purposes, both offline and online (for example, use of electronic communications, spamming, profiling, and use of cookies).
Comparative advertising against competing products is allowed only if:
In cases of unlawful comparative advertising, the Italian Competition Authority (Autorita' Garante della Concorrenza e del Mercato) (ICA) can impose fines ranging from EUR5,000 to EUR500,000.
Such advertising may, in addition, be considered an unfair commercial practice under Article 21(2)(a) of the Consumer Code. In this case, the ICA can impose fines of either:
(Article 27(9-bis), Legislative Decree no 206/2005) (see Price Comparisons).
For additional information on advertising laws in Italy, see Country Q&A, Advertising in Italy: Overview.
The use of data of participants must be in accordance with the Data Protection Code which aligns with the GDPR.
For additional information on privacy laws, see Country Q&A, Data Protection in Italy: Overview.
Prize promotions, such as prize draws, instant win games, and skill contests, are commonly used to incentivise consumer purchase decisions. They are heavily regulated to help prevent deceptive and unfair practices. Businesses need to be careful to avoid conducting an illegal lottery.
The difference between lotteries and other prize contests is particularly relevant because in Italy the fine for organising an event in violation of the state gaming monopoly can be up to EUR500,000 (Article 4, paragraph 4-bis, Law no 401 of 13 December 1989, which refers to Article 124, Royal Decree no 1933 of 19 October 1938) (see Contest).
The distinction between the different types of initiatives is based on the cost for participating. For example, in prize draws, participation must be free by law, while in lotteries it is necessary to buy tickets.
In Italy, only the state and its licensees can organise a lottery. Running an unauthorised lottery is punishable by imprisonment from three to six years and by a fine ranging from EUR20,000 to EUR50,000 (Article 4, paragraph 1, Law no 401 of 13 December 1989 as amended).
The unauthorised advertising of lotteries is punishable with imprisonment of up to three months and a fine of between EUR51 and EUR516 (Article 4, paragraph 2, Law no 401 of 13 December 1989).
The awarding of prizes is conducted in the presence of a public official responsible for consumer protection and public trust (typically a representative of the Chamber of Commerce) (Article 9, PD 430/2001).
If the mechanism adopted for the awarding of the prizes requires technical knowledge, the notary must be supported by an appropriate expert. The notary is responsible for ensuring compliance with public trust and consumer protection rights. They must draw up a record of the relevant operations.
In Italy, two kinds of sales promotion involving prizes are permitted:
Provisions Prize competitions and operations are regulated by PD 430/2001. The most important provisions include:
Fines for prize competitions associated with gaming activities reserved for the state or that breach the state monopoly on gaming, range from EUR50,000 to EUR500,000. Fines are doubled if the competition continues to be held after its prohibition.(Article 124. Royal Decree no 1933 of 19 October 1938 amended by Article 1, paragraph 924, letter p of Law no 208/2015).
If a promoter fails to notify the Ministry of Economic Development of its intention to hold a competition, it is liable to a fine of between EUR2,065.83 and EUR10,329.14 (Article 12, PD 430/2001, which refers to Article 124, Royal Decree no 1933 of 19 October 1938).
The fine is reduced by 50% if the notification is sent after the competition has started, but before the promoter has been found in breach.
If a competition is subsequently held under rules different from those originally notified, fines of between EUR1,032.91 and EUR5,164.57 can be imposed (Article 124, paragraph 4, Royal Decree no 1933 of 19 October 1938).
Italian law does not regulate the use of tie-breakers in a competition. Rules of the prize competition generally apply. However, the protection of the participants is ensured by the notary responsible for public trust and consumer protection rights (see Prize Draws).
Italian law considers prize promotions to be an offer to the public. An offer to the public is an offer to make a contract which binds the offeror towards those subjects interested in the offer. It can be revoked provided that the revocation is made in the same form or in equivalent form as the offer (Article 1336, Civil Code (Codice civile)). A public offer is a contractual proposal addressed to a generality of recipients wishing to take advantage of it. The conditions of the public offer can be drafted in the form of terms and conditions.
Any advertisement that can reach children or teenagers, directly or indirectly, which threatens their safety is deemed misleading (Article 21, paragraph 4, Consumer Code).
Marketing communications must not include a direct exhortation to children to buy an advertised product or persuade their parents or other adults to buy an advertised product for them as this is deemed an aggressive business practice (Article 26, paragraph 1, letter (e), Consumer Code).
Special care must be taken when directing or exposing messages to children (that is, any person up to 12 years of age) and young people (Article 11, Marketing Code (Children and young people)). These messages must avoid material that could cause psychological, moral, or physical harm, and must not exploit the credulity, inexperience, or sense of loyalty of children or young people. In particular, the Marketing Code prohibits advertising that may induce children and young people to:
Food and beverages advertising directed at, or exposed to, at children is also subject to the provisions contained in the Marketing Code.
Further, marketing communication for games, toys, and educational products for children must not be misleading (Article 28 bis, Marketing Code).
Any company, including non-EU companies and those without a registered office in Italy, can carry out a web-based prize event in Italy.
Any platform can be used to collect the participants' data, including those located abroad, provided that the activities related to the elimination stages and the identification of winners or assignment of prizes take place in Italy (Article 1, paragraph 6, and Article 9, PD 430/2001).
This means that the server for managing preference systems, random detection systems, user interaction systems, and systems that exploit gaming skills must be located in Italy. The promoting entity must provide for the secure transfer, with a mirroring or similar system to an Italian server, of the data necessary for performing the activities necessary for the identification of winners and the consequent assignment of prizes.
With particular reference to online prize promotions on social network platforms, if the only way to participate in a prize event is via a social network platform, the promotion is limited to those who are registered with the relevant social network platform before the start date of the event.
The promoter or related delegate must verify that the registration date is true. It is advisable to include in the terms and conditions of the promotion that the promoter or delegate reserves the right to ask participants or winners (or both), at any point of the prize event, for proof of their registration on the social network platform before the start date of the prize promotion and that, if it is not provided, the participant or winner (or both) will be excluded.
For example, if Facebook's mechanics only allow participation or registration through Facebook connect (therefore, without the additional email and password option), the participant must have been registered with Facebook before the start date of the event and the personal data extracted from Facebook's archive must be automatically registered on a server located in Italy.
Online prize promotions involve the processing of participants' personal data and the applicable guidelines and laws must be respected. For example, the guidelines of the Italian Data Protection Authority (Garante per la protezione dei dati personali) provide general guidance on the processing of personal data for online profiling, and should be followed when processing personal data for the purposes of the online prize promotion and for profiling activities.
Prize operations and competitions falling within the scope of PD 430/2001 are subject to specific tax rules.
Typically, the promoter of a prize operation or competition is a withholding agent that withholds taxes on prizes awarded to parties (Article 30, Presidential Decree no 600 of 29 September 1973, to be replaced, without substantive amendments, by Article 45 of Legislative Decree no 33 of 24 March 2025 with effect from 1 January 2027).
For the beneficiary, the prizes awarded may be considered taxable income. Where prizes are awarded in kind, withholding tax applies on the normal value of the prizes, and is determined for the beneficiary under Article 9 of Presidential Decree no 917 of 22 December 1986 (Presidential Decree no 917/1986), net of value added tax.
Prize operations are subject to the following rules:
Prize competitions are subject to the following rules:
The input VAT incurred by the promoter on goods and services used for prize promotions is non-deductible (Article 19, paragraph 2, Presidential Decree no. 633 of 26 October 1972 (Italian VAT Code)).
The cost of prizes is deductible for CIT and IRAP purposes.
For CIT purposes, as the term of the prize operations or competitions often expires after the end of the fiscal year, under certain conditions, promoters can deduct an amount of up to 30% (in the case of prize operations) and 70% (in the case of prize competitions) of the provisions on account of expenses arising from the prize operation or competition. Any such provision, or portion of a provision, not used by the end of the third fiscal year following its formation is added back to taxable income for that year (Article 107, Presidential Decree no 917/1986).
Businesses use a variety of price promotions to incentivise consumers to buy their products and services. Common strategies include discounts, free offers, coupons, and rebates. When structuring a consumer price promotion, companies need to comply with applicable laws and regulations governing the price promotion itself and the advertising of pricing.
It is important to distinguish between different types of price promotions, as regulated by Legislative Decree no 114/1998, such as seasonal sales, liquidation sales, and promotional sales.
Prices of products must be displayed to consumers in a clear and legible fashion, with a price tag or a similar means (Article 14, Legislative Decree no 114/1998). Each infringement is punishable by a fine ranging from EUR516.46 to EUR3,098.74 (Article 22, paragraph 3, Legislative Decree no 114/1998).
Under the Marketing Code, price advertisements must:
Similarly, extraordinary sales and liquidation sales must be truthful and not misleading (for example, they must not attract people by advertising reduced prices while products are being sold at normal prices).
Italian law distinguishes three types of extraordinary sales:
(Article 15, Legislative Decree no 114/1998; Article 3, Law Decree no 223 of 4 July 2006, converted by Law no 248 of 4 August 2006.)
Below-cost sales are allowed, subject to the following conditions:
(Article 1, Presidential Decree no 218/2001.)
Italian law prohibits below-cost sales when they are performed by a retailer which, acting alone or jointly with other entities within the same group, holds more than 50% of the overall sale area of a product category, in the province where the business is located (Article 1, Presidential Decree no 218/2001).
Italian law does not establish significant restrictions on price reductions during sales events. Commercial operators can determine the price of products offered to consumers. The possibility to freely determine the price of products gives promoters many possibilities in setting up sales events. However, below-cost sales are illegal if conducted by a company holding a dominant position in the market (so-called "predatory pricing") (Article 3, Law no 287/1990) and, under certain circumstances, are considered in breach of unfair competition rules (see Article 2598, Civil Code; Article 6, Presidential Decree no 218/2001).
Regional laws play an increasingly important role in regulating promotional sales.
In January 2012, the Italian government introduced a package of liberalisation measures, including special rules on discounts by newsagents and regarding the sale of pharmaceuticals (Articles 11 and 39, Law Decree no 1 of 24 January 2012, converted by Law no 27 of 24 March 2012).
Generally, loss-leading practices are allowed in Italy as commercial operators are free to determine the price of products offered to consumers. However, loss-leading is illegal if conducted by a company that has a dominant position in the market and is selling products below production cost (predatory pricing) (Article 3, Law no 287/1990).
Businesses often advertise discounts in comparison to other prices, such as its prior price, or in the case of introductory offers, its future prices. Price comparisons can also be made against the competition or in some cases, against a list price or manufacturer's suggested retail price. These price comparisons are subject to restrictions to ensure they are not deceptive.
In particular, to improve consumer information and facilitate comparison of prices, products offered by traders to consumers must bear, in addition to the indication of the selling price, the indication of the price per unit, unless it is the same as the selling price (Article 14, Consumer Code).
However, the obligation to indicate the unit price of products does not apply if this indication would not be useful because of the product's nature or purpose or would be liable to cause confusion (Article 16, Consumer Code). A trader who fails to indicate the unit price is subject to a fine set out under Article 22, paragraph 3 of Legislative Decree no 114/1998 (that is, a fine of between EUR516 and EUR3,098) (Article 17, Consumer Code).
On 18 March 2023, Legislative Decree no 26 of 7 March 2023 transposing the Omnibus Directive (2019/2161/EU) was published in the Italian Official Journal. The new rules apply as of 2 April 2023. The only exception concerns the provisions regarding the "prior price" in the framework of announcements of a price reduction, which will apply starting from 1 July 2023.
Regarding price reduction rules, Article 1 of Legislative Decree 26/2023 introduces further obligations on traders (Article 17 bis of Legislative Decree 206/2005). In particular, the trader must indicate in each announcement of a price reduction the prior price and the current reduced price of the product. The prior price means the lowest price applied by the trader during a period not shorter than 30 days before the application of the price reduction.
This 30-day rule does not apply to price reduction announcements for:
Sales below cost do not fall within the scope of this new rule.
Article 17-bis of the Consumer Code provides that a violation of the rules on price reduction announcements is punishable by an administrative fine ranging from EUR516 to EUR3,098 (set out under Article 22, paragraph 3 of Legislative Decree no 114/1998).
Introductory offers qualify as promotional sales (see Discounts). Therefore, they can only be set up for a limited time (Article 15, Legislative Decree no 114/1998).
From an anti-trust perspective, introductory offers that are loss-leading or otherwise at prices that are not immediately remunerative are in breach of Article 102 of the TFEU and Article 3 of Law no 287/1990 if they are put in place by a company holding a dominant position and practiced with predatory purposes of suppressing competition, therefore resulting in harm to consumers and the market.
Further, Article 2598 n. 3 of the Civil Code provides that it constitutes an unfair competition practice to directly or indirectly make use of any means not in accordance with the principles of professional fairness and suitable to cause damage to another's business. Therefore, in principle, if a trader offers their goods or services at prices below production prices to acquire competitors' customers and drive them out of the market, then this may constitute an unfair competition practice in breach of Article 2598 n. 3 of the Civil Code if it is contrary to the principles of professional fairness.
Comparisons against a competitor's prices may constitute an abuse of a dominant position if it leads to predatory pricing.
Restrictions on sale prices are prohibited. However, if the market share of the supplier and the buyer, in their respective sale and purchase markets, are below 30%, the supplier is allowed to impose a maximum or recommended sale price, provided that this does not amount to a fixed price or minimum sale price as a result of pressure from, or incentives offered by, any of the parties (Article 101, TFEU; Article 2, Law no 287/1990; EU Vertical Agreements Block Exemption Regulation (330/2010) (and its successor, Regulation 2022/720) the non-binding Vertical Restraints Guidelines (and its successor 2022 Guidelines)).
Promotions offering additional quantities of the same product purchased, or price discounts on products or services of the same kind as those purchased, are not considered prize operations. Discounts on different products or services are also excluded, provided they are not offered to promote the latter (Article 6(c), PD 430/2001).
In Italy, vouchers, coupons, and cross-couponing are considered discount offers. Competitions where prizes are in the form of discount offers are not considered prize competitions or operations subject to regulation under PD 430/2001. (See Contest.)
Cashback schemes are considered discounts similar to those applied at the time of purchase and not prize operations (Resolution no 147/E of 10 April 2008 issued by the Italian Tax Authority - Directorate General for Regulations and Litigation, General information on prize competitions (FAQ) - Version updated as at 13 February 2020).
Italian law considers sales promotions to be an offer to the public. An offer to the public is an offer to make a contract which binds the offeror towards those subjects interested in the offer. It can be revoked provided that the revocation is made in the same form or in equivalent form as the offer (Article 1336, Civil Code).
Consumers have various options for lodging complaints against a business for a price or prize promotion it has conducted. These promotions may also be subject to regulatory enforcement. Businesses may face significant penalties for conducting a promotion that does not comply with the law.
If there is a breach of any of the rules outlined in Fundamental Advertising Principles, interested parties can:
The ICA can act on its own initiative or following a complaint. It has investigative powers to access any relevant document, request information and documents, and impose penalties. In the event of refusal to comply with its orders, or if untruthful information and documents are submitted, the ICA has the power to conduct inspections, use the officers of the Customs and Excise Police (Guardia di Finanza), and order expert testimony.
The ICA can:
The ICA can, in the above cases, impose fines of up to 4% of the trader's annual turnover in Italy or in the EU member states affected by the alleged violation (paragraph 9-bis, Legislative Decree no 206/2005, implementing Article 21 of the Consumer Protection Co-operation Regulation (2017/2394)). Where information on annual turnover is not available, the ICA can impose fines of up to EUR2 million (Article 27, paragraph 9-bis, Legislative Decree 206/2005).
Non-compliance with the ICA's measures can incur a fine of between:
Precautionary measures can also be adopted in urgent cases.
As a general rule, consumer sales promotions must comply with the constitutional principles of freedom of speech, religion, and self-determination, and not discriminate on any ground such as, gender, sexual orientation, political views, religious beliefs, social and economic condition, and so on. Any advertisement activity in violation of these principles may be prohibited.
From a practical standpoint, companies that run promotions in Italy are advised to assess at the earliest stage possible the legal framework applicable to each promotion and track timely compliance with the applicable legal requirements (for example, a description of the prize competition must be submitted to the Ministry of Economic Development at least 15 calendar days before the beginning of the competition).
The authors thank Luca Luci (International trainee) for his contributions to the article.
Publication
HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. announced that the CMS would exercise exclusion authority to remove “bad actors” from federal healthcare programs “effective immediately.”
Publication
Now in its seventh year, our annual English Premier League (EPL) football report, Keeping Possession, captures insights from our global sports law team on the key trends and topics shaping the landscape of English football.
Subscribe and stay up to date with the latest legal news, information and events . . .
© Norton Rose Fulbright LLP 2026